From Feasible to Practical: Pareto-Optimal Synthesis Planning

Current computer-aided synthesis planning (CASP) methods often treat retrosynthesis as solved once a single feasible route is identified, focusing primarily on convergence or shortest-path metrics. This view is misaligned with real-world practice, where chemists must balance competing objectives such as cost, sustainability, toxicity, and overall yield. To address this, we formulate synthesis planning as a multi-objective search problem and introduce MORetro$^\ast$, an algorithm that generates a Pareto front of synthesis routes to explicitly capture trade-offs between user-defined criteria. MORetro$^\ast$ uses weighted scalarization and solution-informed sampling to efficiently navigate the combinatorial search space and prioritize promising trade-offs. Building on multi-objective A$^\ast$-search, we provide optimality guarantees showing that, for a fixed single-step model, MORetro$^\ast$ recovers the true Pareto front. Across multiple retrosynthesis benchmarks, MORetro$^\ast$ produces diverse, high-quality Pareto fronts, uncovering solutions overlooked by single-objective approaches and better aligning CASP outputs with industrial decision-making.